Practicum 2 – Sarah Curns

For this assignment, I asked people what their thoughts were about the media. I asked my dad, my sister, and my co-worker about their opinions and thoughts about the relationship between the media and politics. Here are the questions I asked them: 

  1. What do you think about political media today?
  2. Do you think the media has changed over time? If yes how so?
  3. Do you think that the internet is more helpful or hindering to our current political world?
  4. Do you think that political parties have become more polarized? 
  5. How do you primarily get your news information? 

Starting off with my sister Rachel who is 18 years old, I learned that they have a pretty good understanding of the media and politics for someone who hasn’t taken this class. When asked about what they thought about political media they said that there’s a lot of misinformation out there that people tend to believe in. They said that people are less likely to do research on complicated topics and just believe what they hear at face value. They think that this problem will only get worse from here on out. They also talked about how the internet ultimately hinders our political world because of how easily misinformation spreads and can get people to believe information that is objectively false. However, Rachel also added that the internet can be helpful for bringing light to things that are happening that the traditional media is trying to sweep under the rug. While they didn’t discuss echo chambers and filter bubbles, I think they were alluding to those concepts when talking about how information on social media can be so divided. They also discussed the topic of the information commons and how people used to be exposed to the same information through the same 3 news channels and the local newspaper. Because people were all working with the same information they all had a baseline understanding of what was going on which is helpful when having political discussions. Now there’s an abundance of different news options so everyone is working with different information which makes it harder to understand each other, according to Rachel. When asked about the polarization of political parties Rachel said that they think people have become more polarized because of social media and the influence of celebrities. The way that Rachel gets their news is through Twitter, TikTok, and the headlines of articles from Apple News. According to the textbook, using social media as a primary source for news can be a bad idea as the coverage tends to be one-sided and one could only receive news that the algorithm thinks they want to hear. Overall, I learned that Rachel has a pretty good understanding of the dangers of social media when it comes to the news. However, they primarily partake in this same behavior which means that these problems could also be affecting them. 

Next, I interviewed my dad who is 54 years old. His main focus when answering these questions was that he didn’t want people’s opinions to be shaping his own. He thinks that people should be able to get the basic information and then form their own opinions from that information. He thinks that the media was better back when he was a child because there were less options and people all got to work with the same information. Again, he’s referring to the information commons where there was a low-choice media system. He thinks that news was less biased and more reliable back then. When talking about the question of whether the internet was helpful to political discourse or not he said that it was not. Back in the day, people chose when and how they consumed their news even if there weren’t many choices. However, now the news is inescapable and intertwined with so many things. You can’t enjoy scrolling through Facebook to connect with family and friends without seeing something about the news. Consumption of media used to be more intentional and now you don’t really control what you see at all. Also, he doesn’t like that algorithms control what you’re exposed to regarding the news. Onto the political polarization question, he thinks that people have become a lot more politically divided. He thinks that people used to get along no matter what their political beliefs were and that now people love to hate each other. He thinks this is because of social media and how everyone has to share their opinions about everything with everyone. He primarily gets his news from right-wing talk radio shows, online articles, and television programs like the GlennBeck show. He thinks that these news sources are unbiased and reliable and that they don’t serve as entertainment as the book says. It was interesting to learn about my dad’s interpretation of how the news has changed over time, especially since he experienced it first-hand.

Lastly, I interviewed my co-worker, Mike who is 33 years old. His primary focus when answering the questions was that people are in media to make money and they don’t care about being accurate or unbiased. When asked about what he thought about the media in general he said that they are untrustworthy because the news is run by private companies that are just trying to make money. He thinks that the news ultimately changed in the 1980s when CNN went to 24-hour news coverage. This made the news more entertaining because you need filler stories to fill the time and to keep people interested you need interesting stories that may not be important or even inaccurate. This idea is discussed in the book as the entertainment function, in order to keep people watching the news, it needs to be entertaining. Publisher William Randolph Hearst said that “he would prefer a novelty that is not a fact to a fact that is not a novelty.” I think it is this idea that Mike is getting at when he talks about how the news has to be entertaining. Although the textbook says that the need for the news to be exciting has been a phenomenon that’s existed since the start of media. When asked about the internet Mike ultimately thought that it was severely hurting our political world. He talked about how easy it is for misinformation and disinformation to spread and how difficult it is to fix that. To quote him he said, “It’s super easy to convince someone of something stupid, just a meme is normally enough to have them dismiss, say, the rights of a minority group, but it takes significant research and explaining to actually prove them wrong.” Another reason he thought the Internet was ruining political discourse is because of the lack of nuance there is when having political discourse. People’s attention spans have gone down severely probably due to short-form content like TikTok so people don’t spend very long thinking about complex issues. If it’s difficult to find information people often won’t do it because they’ve moved on to the next issue. While there is correct information out there, it’s getting more difficult to find. On to the question about political polarization, he says that the entire two-party system is to divide people. Republicans and Democrats both shun their own for voting against party lines which keeps them even more divided. Finally, talking about media consumption he says he mostly reads AP News and the Hill. He reports that they are both ranked pretty unbiasedly, with the former having a slight left lean and the latter, right. Overall, I learned a lot from this conversation and heard some opinions that I had never heard before.

Overall, I really enjoyed this assignment and thought it was useful for the real world. After learning all about these topics, I liked getting to put my knowledge to the test and have actual conversations with people about these topics. I think you should use this assignment in the future, especially with how people are becoming more politically polarized and are less willing to hear the other side out. Having personal and productive conversations about politics is the best way of getting a political understanding of one another and the best way to change people’s minds.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.